Back to all articles
In-house teams5 min read

Choosing marketing tools without ending up with twelve subscriptions

Rob Oxborough
Rob Oxborough
Founder, oXo Creatives
An open notebook with blank, stitched pages on a dark wooden desk

Five tools cover most of what a small marketing team needs, and four of them cost nothing. Make every tool after that argue for its place, because subscriptions pile up one at a time, and each is easy to justify on its own. Before long nobody can say what half of them are for, and the annual total is a serious sum.

The discipline that matters isn't choosing well. It's cancelling the ones that have stopped earning their place.

The five that earn their place

  • Somewhere to see the work. Have one board, of whatever kind, that everyone uses. Which tool it is matters far less than its being the only one.
  • Analytics on your website, set up so the numbers mean something. It's free, but it's useless until somebody defines what counts as a result. Setting up GA4 key events is that job, and the five reports you need show you how to read the numbers afterwards.
  • Google Search Console, Google's free tool for seeing how your site appears in search, and the only place where some of that is visible at all. It needs ten minutes a month, as the monthly check sets out.
  • Your business listings, principally the Google Business Profile, which is free and, for a local business, usually the highest-return thing you own.
  • Something to send email with. This is the first of the five that most teams should actually pay for. Deliverability, meaning whether your emails reach the inbox, is worth money, and the free tiers run out exactly when your mailing list starts working.

Paid advertising platforms aren't on the list because they're a channel rather than a tool: they cost what you spend through them.

Four questions before you add anything

  1. What will we stop doing, or stop paying for, because of this? If the answer is nothing, you're adding cost and work.
  2. Who will own it? A tool with no name against it becomes nobody's, and then it becomes a renewal nobody questions.
  3. What happens to our data if we leave? Ask before you start, not when you want out: how the export works, what format it's in, and whether the history comes with you. It's the same thinking as who owns your marketing accounts, applied to software.
  4. Does it only work if somebody keeps using it? Most tools fail not because they're bad but because they need a habit nobody has. A tool that needs daily discipline from a team of two will be abandoned in a month.

The traps

Buying a tool to fix a process problem. If work goes missing because nobody agreed who decides, a new board won't fix it. It will host the same confusion in a nicer interface.

The free tier that isn't really free. It's fine until your mailing list grows, your contacts pass a threshold or you need the one feature that matters. Check the price at twice your current size before you commit, because moving to another tool later is the expensive part.

Buying for the team you want. Tools built for large companies assume a department, with approval chains, user roles and dedicated administrators. A team of three gets the overhead and none of the benefit.

One more place the truth lives. Every additional tool is another place where your customer list, your numbers or your plan can drift apart. Fewer places means fewer arguments about which number is right.

How to kill one

Twice a year, list every subscription with its annual cost, its owner and the date somebody last opened it. Then ask a single question of each one: if this disappeared tomorrow, what would actually break?

Anything where the answer is "nothing much" goes, and a surprising number of answers are "nothing much". Give it a month's notice internally in case somebody speaks up, then cancel it. Show whoever signs off the budget what you saved, because it makes the next audit much easier to schedule.

When a tool is worth real money

A tool is worth real money in three cases. The first is when it saves a person a day a month, every month. The second is when it does something that would otherwise be done badly, and doing it badly would be serious, as with email deliverability or consent. The third is when it's the record of something you can't afford to lose, such as your customer list.

Everything else is a convenience, and conveniences should be cheap. The same reasoning decides what the team should do itself, which is what a marketing skills audit is for.

If you'd like somebody to run the audit with you, and to be the one asking what would break, that's a day of our fractional and part-time marketing leadership.

Rob Oxborough
Written by Rob Oxborough

I founded oXo Creatives, an independent marketing agency and consultancy, in 2013 and run it full-time. Until 2026 I ran it alongside senior in-house marketing roles at Google, PlayStation and King, partner management at Meta, and digital product at NatWest.

Want help with marketing leadership?

Senior marketing judgement a few days a month, for a team that has the hands but not the direction. A regular rhythm of fixed days, agreed in advance, with a review after the first quarter.

What's included

Good for